Brazing TC tips.

Joined
Jul 29, 2018
Messages
799
Reaction score
531
Location
Huddersfield. UK.
Country
United Kingdom
Hi,

I have a friend who owns a company where Tungsten Carbide tooling is used manually in a long handle to trim aluminium; brass and steel whilst these are turning at speed and giving an intermittent cut; this cut is punishing to the tool tip and cheap tooling simply isn't up to the job.

During a visit to the works I was shown a TC tip that had failed this having been brazed in-house but a good example of the problem needing to be resolved. My friend had bought 22 high quality tips and asked if I could possibly solve the problem or have suggestions for him which of course I was more than happy to try. As I looked closely at the failed tool in my hand the tip had been thrown; it appeared to me the cause was a dry brazing joint; the guy who had done the brazing was called into the office and I asked him please to take his time and explain exactly his method of brazing the tip. He had followed normal brazing methods but one point really stood out; as the tool reached brazing temperature and the bronze filler started to flow he pressed on the tip with a screwdriver to bring the tip into close proximity with the tool body as the heat was turned off; on the face of it he had done nothing wrong at all.

I returned home with the TC tips and a short length of 3/8" square bright mild steel bar stock to experiment with. I've not done any brazing for about 50 years so here was a nice challenge although once learnt it's not forgotten; I still had a tin of brazing flux.

In the workshop I set about cutting the bar stock into short lengths; I was told it would be OK to simply braze the tip onto the end of the tool but this was the first change I made; I decided to form a recessed "land" for the tip so using hacksaw and engineers files I cut the land giving a snug fit for the tip. A lot of thought was given to the dry joint problem and if I followed the same method previously used my joints too would surely fail? I bought silicon bronze brazing rods but I also wondered if it would be possible to use silicon bronze in shim form? Unfortunately I couldn't find such shim on the web but I did find brass shim so I bought a small sheet of 0.5mm brass sheet to experiment with.

Having gathered everything and bought more bar stock I was ready but the dry joint was troubling me; how could I prevent a dry joint? I dreamt up an answer whilst in bed at about 3am thinking it over; could I gently center pop the land throwing up a circular round burr thereby lifting the tip giving a gap for the filler to flow but not be pressed out.

I was keen to try this out and fired up my big paraffin blowlamp; this proved useless the blowlamp wouldn't heat the tool to cherry red so I then tried my MAPP gas torch; it took a lot of heat but at last the tool was cherry red and the filler flowed. I had set the tool in the vice at an angle giving good secure access; SIF Bronze powder was mixed with a drop of water to form a paste; the paste was brushed onto the land then in turn the brass shim added and this was brushed with paste then the tip was added.

How could the tip be held in position during brazing; I had made a pair of "third hands" to use during TIG welding and one of these proved perfect giving just enough pressure. Care was taken not to linger with the heat once the brass melted and I was delighted when the tool cooled to see it had worked perfectly; I made a first batch of ten using the brass then the second batch I used the bronze filler rod this time dipping the hot end of the filler rod into the powder flux allowing the filler to run into the joint.

I must add that cleanliness is very important; the joint and TC tip needs to be very clean indeed; The tool body was clean after all the filing but the TC tips were very rough indeed; the only way I could clean these was to laboriously rub them on a bench diamond hone with water as lubricant; I rubbed the face to be the joint and also all four sides on each tip bringing them up shiny clean.

TC Tips (2).JPG


TC tips before honing and after honing; cleanliness is so important.

TC Tips (10).JPG


Here an hacksaw has been used to rough out waste for the lands taking a lot of care not to cut too deep.

TC Tips (13).JPG


A land being hand filed; note shoulder protection to run the file true.

TC Tips (12).JPG


The three shallow center pops I dreamt up in action.

TC Tips (3).JPG


0.5mm brass shim added; I even used 240G abrasive paper to scuff the new brass shim.

TC Tips (1).JPG


Tool bodies ready to receive TC tips with the experimental tool in front which was successful.

Brazing_0001.JPG


The brazing set up using the third hand.

TC Tips (4).JPG


Tool production under way.

TC Tips (7).JPG


The bench diamond hone which was slow but did a good job.

TC Tips (8).JPG


Here's an home made high speed diamond hone I made years ago using a cheap woodworking router.

Due to the raging Corona virus I posted the first batch of tooling to my friend and after testing he phoned to say he was delighted with their performance; later I posted the second batch of tooling and I was pleased both batches came up to expectations. My friend has a milling machine for adding lands on further tooling but I'm unable to visit due to the virus. I've requested he buy 50 more TC tips and sufficient bar stock because I'm keen to try something really different as an experiment; not the usual DIY project but something I'm interested in trying.

I like to experiment and at times I'm barking mad but nothing ventured nothing gained.


This is hardly basic DIY but I've now bought a commercial 1,950W microwave transformer but not to make a metal melter from I want to experiment making a brazing machine but I need to tame the power of the transformer to suit my needs; I've wound many transformers over the years so the work isn't new to me but using a transformer for this project is totally new to me.

Just to give an idea of what I'm dreaming up; I can't easily control the transformer output amps unless I add more secondary turns or add a load in series but my idea is to control the supply input volts and have bought a motor speed controller;

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/4000W-220V-AC-SCR-Voltage-Regulator-Dimmer-Electric-Motor-Speed-Controller-TE474/143081510744?ssPageName=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649

Watts = Amps x Volts; by controlling the input voltage can I control the output amps? As I say I'm barking mad and need to be careful not to encourage others to follow my lead because a project like this at mains electricity supply can and will kill given the slightest chance; my problem is getting decent workshop time due to more pressing jobs around home and gardens.

If I can succeed with the brazing machine then another project involves induction heating; my friend with the business needs to anneal large stainless steel products so I'll look into this; in the meantime I've bought an induction heater to play with just to get the feel of it then I hope to build an induction heater from scratch to give industrial performance but without industrial costs?

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ZVS-Induction-Heating-Board-Module-2500W-Driver-Heater-Tesla-Coil-Dual/193336955666?ssPageName=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&var=493528743914&_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649




I hope my ramblings are of interest; I'm never bored.

Kind regards, Colin.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
84
Reaction score
8
As far as induction heating , ages ago I worked at a grey iron foundry that used 2 induction furnaces to melt the iron .

I have also read literature for using "rings " of silver solder to braze copper tubing for refrigeration / air conditioning refrigerant piping . The " rings " were Sil-Flos brand .


Do not know if a variation on this would be useful on tthe TC ?

God bless
Wyr
 
Joined
Jul 29, 2018
Messages
799
Reaction score
531
Location
Huddersfield. UK.
Country
United Kingdom
Hi,

Many thanks for your reply WyrTwister. I've used solder ring fittings many times;


I'm unsure if silver solder would be strong enough to braze these TC tips?

Kind regards, Colin.
 
Joined
Jul 29, 2018
Messages
799
Reaction score
531
Location
Huddersfield. UK.
Country
United Kingdom
Hi,

Many thanks for the information Doug; I've never tried silver solder so you've a lot more experience than I have on the subject.

I've just had a quick browse of the web;

"The melting point of the various silver solders can range from under 200 ˚C to some greater than 360 ˚C, but most of the solders in general hobby use (including most lead free alloys) have melt temperature in the range of 215 ˚C to 220 ˚C (419 ˚F to 428 ˚F). This is only 20 to 30 °C higher than 60/40 tin / lead (183 °C / 351 °F) but substantially below 750 ˚F (399 ˚C). If your silver solder is not melting with your iron set to 750 °F, I would suspect that your iron is out of calibration or you have a very high temperature solder."

However I've used both brass and bronze for brazing the tips and brass melting range is;


"900 to 940 °C
The relatively low melting point of brass (900 to 940 °C, 1,650 to 1,720 °F, depending on composition) and its flow characteristics make it a relatively easy material to cast. By varying the proportions of copper and zinc, the properties of the brass can be changed, allowing hard and soft brasses."

A lot of difference in melting points and it depends on the individual application; the tips I brazed are subjected to extreme shock unlike lathe TC tipped tooling which is a lot more gentle.

Update; I've done a bit more web browsing and found more information this time when I searched for hard silver soldering;

Easy has a melt temperature of 1235 F and a flow temperature of 1325 F. Medium has a melt temperature of 1265 F and a flow temperature of 1390 F. Hard has a melt temperature of 1330 F and a flow temperature of 1475 F.12 Jul 2014

This is an interesting subject though.

Kind regards, Colin.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Apr 2, 2015
Messages
84
Reaction score
8
I have watched several " machinist videos " on YouTube involving silver solder . But almost all of my real life observations are from watching HVAC technicians use Sil-Fos to silver solder A/C & refrigeration copper tubing .

God bless
Wyr

 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Top